Are Large Corporations Treated Differently? Pfizer $2 Billion False Claims Act Settlement Is Its Second In Six Years

viagra_pills.jpgOften, we hear that white collar crime is treated differently than other types of crime. However, it is often who commits white collar crime that brings about different treatment. I had a client indicted for fraud related to a DME. Monthly, he would send me articles about large DME companies paying large fines and false claims settlements for the same conduct he was alleged to have engaged in and asked the simple question, “Why am I supposed to go to jail and they don’t?”
People arrested for crimes, and in particular health care fraud can find many rationales for conduct that objectively looks bad; some form the bases for defenses; some are to try to feel better. One reaction is generally the same for nearly all, whether it is speeding or a million dollar fraud, “everyone is doing it.” A variation on that theme, and a fair one is that often individuals and small companies are treated much differently than much larger companies.
In 2004, at the same time Pfizer was negotiating a resolution of a $460 million settlement with the United States for unlawful “off label” uses of its drugs, it also was planning and executing marketing campaigns for other drugs doing precisely the same conduct. The results, a huge fine and restitution, but no criminal charges for individuals. An individual that takes a million dollars in a Medicare fraud scheme is going to jail; as are employees and others most closely associated with that person and the scheme. The world’s largest drug company agreed it participated in a $1 billion in Medicare fraud and pays money. The company, or likely a subsidiary, also plead guilty to a crime, but no person goes to jail. $2 billion is not a small sum, but many sitting in prison wonder why the rules are different.
Currently, the highest dollar “amount of loss” category for sentencing purposes involving fraud is for a loss figure of $400,000,000 or more, garnering a 30 level sentencing enhancement; whereas $1,000,000 or more will get a 16 level enhancement. If someone participated in a scheme with a resulting loss of $1million dollars, they are likely to go to prison for a minimum (without other adjustments) of 41 months. This sentence could be applicable to the person who masterminded the scheme as well as some low level employee who merely assisted. A person who participates in a scheme with a resulting loss of $1 billion would be subject to prison for a minimum of 188 months; however in this case, no one goes to jail. Clients complain, “the rich (corporate defendants) get richer, while the poor (individual defendant) gets prison.”
Click here to read more.